‘Here’s what I think,’ I continued. ‘You made the bet because you wanted to see me naked. I made the bet because I wanted to see you and your friends naked.’
Geoff waved his hand by the side of his body. ‘Why would you …’ He didn’t finish the sentence.
‘Guys look beautiful naked. At least, I think they look beautiful naked. I think you look beautiful naked. I think your cock is part of your beauty and that’s the reason why I want you to move the towel.’
He didn’t shift his covering but he did relax his grip. I took that as a positive sign.
Some messages are easier to communicate through physical contact than words. ‘Roll over onto your belly,’ I suggested. ‘I’ll put more sunscreen on your back.’
That’s where I started, below his shoulders, though my hands were soon wandering into places he could easily have reached on his own. My touch was not that of a mother putting sunscreen on her child. After I’d covered him above the waist, I hurried down his body and started on the back of his calves. I continued up along his narrow thighs, careful not to stray too far between them. ‘Tell me if this isn’t OK,’ I said as I got close to round terrain. Geoff didn’t object so I rubbed lotion over his ass, cupping the cheeks in my hands as if I was administering a massage.
Shawn swam close to us. He nodded his approval when I saw what I was doing.
I spanked Geoff lightly to signal the end of his treatment. I hoped he would roll over to reveal that my handiwork had triggered a reaction. Instead, the dock shook slightly as Farhan began to climb the ladder. The presence of the other boys meant that my suspicions would go unconfirmed. If Geoff had an erection, he wasn’t going to display it in front of a male audience.
The lack of hard cocks was a disappointment, but watching the boys’ bums roll as they turned somersaults in the water kept me entertained.
A little past mid-afternoon, when everyone was back on the dock, Shawn caught me adjusting the seat of my bathing suit. ‘If you took it off, you probably would be more comfortable.’
It wasn’t the first time I’d heard that suggestion over the last three hours, but I’d always responded with just a smile.
‘I think you’re right. I would be more comfortable.’ I pulled at one of the straps where it joined the top of the cup, exposing more of my breast momentarily before allowing the fabric to snap back into place. ‘It’s hard to find a bathing suit that fits properly when you’re short and busty like me.’
I paused to add suspense before I announced my decision. Farhan and Geoff had hopeful eyes.
‘I’ll keep it on so we don’t lose the sexy vibe.’
‘That doesn’t make any sense,’ Farhan said. ‘A naked woman makes everything sexier.’
‘If I took off my suit, I’m sure we’d all feel a bit of a rush at first, but the thrill wouldn’t last. When you go to a nude beach, Farhan, how many guys do you see with erect penises?’
It was a teasing question I knew he couldn’t answer. I went ahead and finished my thought.
‘What’s erotic depends a lot on context. If a bunch of people decide to go swimming together without suits, perhaps they’re just being practical. It’s a different dynamic if only some of the people are naked. That means there’s a story. In our case, three naked boys are showing off their bodies for a woman’s pleasure. That registers pretty high on the sexy meter.’
‘You’re objectifying us.’ Geoff looked pleased because he knew he’d said something smart. I guessed our talk had made an impression.
‘Yes – and I’m baffled why none of you are getting hard. Think of all the begging and harassment that goes on from guys who are desperate to find a woman who will glance at their dick pics. You three hit the jackpot and you can’t stop complaining.’
‘I know why Geoff isn’t getting hard.’ Shawn had mischief in his voice. ‘He took precautions this morning to take away the edge.’
I immediately intervened to prevent the exchange of denials and insults that was sure to follow. Putting on my pouty lips, I looked directly into Geoff’s eyes.
‘You did that when I was out on my walk? I wouldn’t have gone if I had known. I’d love to watch you masturbate.’
Before he turned red all over, Geoff got help from Farhan, who said over my head to Shawn, ‘Dude, that’s quite the girlfriend you found.’
‘Is there anyone here who wouldn’t want to watch me masturbate?’
That threw them for a loop.
‘Well, why would it be different for me to want to watch you guys?’
Farhan’s expression hinted at unease. Geoff’s faraway eyes suggested he was imagining me naked with three fingers in my pussy.
‘Here’s the truth: I’d be thrilled to discover how any of you give yourselves pleasure. I’d get so aroused watching you that my nipples would probably poke holes through my bathing suit.’
‘She does like to watch a guy jerk off,’ Shawn said. His cock had started to swell and he wasn?