I forgot to thrust into her because I was mesmerized by what she was doing with that sexy mouth of hers. She hit nerve endings that I’d never really paid attention to. The natural way she listened to my commands made me believe this could really happen—that she would eventually be tied up inside of Ruin.
I pulled my fingers out of her mouth then kissed her hard, my inner monster coming out to play. My hands returned to her voluptuous ass, and my fingers moved to her back entrance, wanting to steer her away from vanilla and to something much darker.
She kissed me with the same passion but immediately tensed when she felt the pressure of my fingers. “What are you doing?” She spoke against my mouth, her lips moving with mine.
I didn’t pull my fingers away. “Feeling you.”
Her pussy was still wet and tight around my length, but she grabbed my arm like her strength could outweigh mine. “I’m not into that.”
I wanted to take this further, to show her a world she would fall in love with. But her hesitance to this new experience concerned me. If she couldn’t do something so simple, she would never let me whip her. “Have you ever tried?”
She slightly rocked her hips, still keeping me inside her. “No…”
“Then how do you know you aren’t into it?” I slipped my finger inside her ass again, saliva lubricating my penetration.
She scooted forward and away from my finger. “It’s an exit only.”
I wrapped my arm tightly around her waist and hooked her close to my chest. After a gentle kiss on the mouth, I spoke. “Whatever reservations you have, forget about them. I’ve never done anything that didn’t make you feel good. Trust me to give you new experiences. Trust me to make you come for me.” I kissed the corner of her mouth and didn’t pull my fingers away, knowing she would allow me entry.
She continued to take my hard dick slowly, her moisture pooling around the base of my cock and my balls.
“Sweetheart.” Despite my frustration, I remained patient. If I couldn’t get her to do this, then there was no way I could convince her to be my sub. “I need you to trust me.”
“I do trust you,” she blurted.
“Then prove it.” I thrust into her from below, my cock sliding in and out of her tight slit. I locked my eyes on hers, silently commanding her to obey me.
Something I said must have changed her mind because she finally agreed. “Okay.”
The excitement in my chest didn’t come from getting what I wanted. It came from the sense of hope that hit me hard in the gut. My instinct about her was right. I could train her to be the perfect submissive—all in good time.
I kissed her as I slid my forefinger through her opening, feeling her body reject me in the beginning. She was tense and nervous, her body unwilling to let me in even though she’d already verbally consented. I breathed into her mouth as I continued to work her ass. “Relax, sweetheart. You can always tell me to stop.”
Gaining the control in the situation finally made her come back into the moment. Her fingertips dug into my shoulders as she kissed me again, allowing me to insert my finger deeper into her ass. Her channel was dangerously tight, much tighter than her pussy. When the time came for me to fuck her in the ass, we might have some problems.
We moved together, my cock stretching her over and over. When she became accustomed to my finger in her ass, she finally became passionate again, kissing me harder and digging her nails into my skin. I moved another finger inside her, stretching her wider apart.
She moaned into my mouth at the intrusion, struggling with the polar emotions. It was an unusual sensation, to be fingered in a place she had never touched, but at the same time, she clearly enjoyed it.
And when she enjoyed it, I enjoyed it.
“Sweetheart…” I wanted to come in her ass and her pussy at the same time. Unfortunately, that wasn’t possible. I’d have to settle for her pussy for now and then her ass later.
“God…” Her lips pulled away from mine as she whimpered. “I’m gonna come.”
I slid a third finger inside her, making it a tight fit. I forced her ass to stretch for my large fingers, pulsing inside her and feeling her tighten. “Come all over my dick, Vanilla.”
She rolled her hips as she took my length several more times until her pussy clenched around me, squeezing me with a death grip. I fingered her harder as she came around me, her moisture pooling even more. “Calloway…”
I stared at her fiery green eyes as I approached my climax, seeing the most beautiful woman in the world sitting on my lap. My fingers were in her ass, and my cock was impaled deep inside her. I had her wrapped around my finger—and she had me wrapped around hers.