Shelby nodded and licked her lips. Mike’s cock was as long as Gavin’s but thicker, and it seemed to be growing before her eyes. Mike took a step closer to Shelby and adjusted the height of the bench up a little so she didn’t have to strain to reach him.
Once he had the bench adjusted to where he wanted it, he checked to make sure she was okay one more time before they started. Her little mouth was open, and her tongue licked her lips again like a kid waiting for an ice cream cone. Using his hand on the sides of her face Mike guided her mouth to his dick just as Gavin let the flogger brush her ass.
Shelby felt the brush of the flogger, but it didn’t sting like she thought it would. It felt more like fingers stroking her skin. She relaxed and let the feeling float over her. Mike still held her head, gently guiding her and showing her how to please him.
Shelby was so swamped with sensations she didn’t even realize when Gavin switched floggers. It wasn’t long before everything started getting floaty.
Mike could see it in her eyes as she drifted off. Gently he pulled himself out of her mouth and nodded to Gavin. Their girl was where they wanted her.
Gavin slowly removed the plug and leaned over Shelby’s back to speak into her ear. They wanted to keep her in that floating feeling until he was inside her.
“Shelby, I’m going to put my cock in your ass now. I want you to relax. If something hurts, use your safe word or raise your hand. Mike and I are right here with you.” He knew she was in sub space but not so deep that she didn’t understand what was going to happen.
Gavin ran his hands over her bottom again and gently parted her cheeks so he could see her little round hole. He put a condom on, then drizzled a little lube over her and applied it generously to his cock. Fitting himself to her, he started slowly pushing in until he had his mushroom-shaped head just past the ring meant to keep intruders out.
Mike was watching her face and nodding so that Gavin knew she was okay. Holding her hips Gavin continued working his way into her going slowly and stretching her carefully. When he was all the way in, he lay over her back and reached around to cup her breasts. Pinching and pulling on the nipples, he licked and nibbled the back of her neck.
Shelby had expected the pain like she had felt before, but Gavin had used plenty of lube and slid right in. It wasn’t uncomfortable at all. He was bigger than any of the plugs they had used, and she felt full, very full. She was glad Gavin was the first to take her there. He was so careful and gentle with her. She knew Mike would be, too. Mike! She was supposed to be taking care of Mike, too.
“Master Mike,” Shelby said in the most seductive voice she could while looking at his erection with a smile, “may I help you with that?”
Mike had been squatting in front of her, watching her closely and reached for her mouth, placing a loving kiss on her lips. “Yes, honey you can.” He stood and again held her head with both hands.
Shelby opened her mouth and took as much of his dick in as she could and swirled her tongue. It felt so good to be able to please both the men. This was what she had been looking for. When she had been reading her books about ménage she had never thought she would be in one, but being here with both these men was amazing. Could she be enough woman to keep both of them happy? It was a question she didn’t know the answer to, but it would be fun trying to find out.
Chapter Eight
Mike slowly fed his cock into Shelby’s mouth and looked up at Gavin, who was standing and was working his way carefully in and out of her rear hole. He couldn’t wait until they took her together, one in her ass and one in her pussy. Then she would truly be theirs. It would be soon, very soon. He wanted to claim this woman and keep her as theirs forever. He needed to talk with Gavin about making things permanent. One of them would have to marry her to make things legal, but she would belong to both of them. Yes, that’s what had to happen, he thought. He didn’t want her getting away.
He watched Gavin’s face and saw emotions he hadn’t seen there before. Shelby wasn’t the first girl they had played with together, but she was the first one they had cared about. It was different with her, it felt more real, more like it was supposed to be. No emotions involved with the others, it had been fun, but that was all. Shelby was the girl for them, no doubt about it.
Gavin watched his cock disappear in and out of Shelby’s little brown hole. He could tell from the way she was moving and the little sounds she was making around Mike’s cock that she was enjoying what was happening. He had made sure to be very careful with her, more careful than he had been with anyone else. She had an unpleasant experience before and didn’t want this one to be bad also.
Mike would want her this way, and Gavin had to make sure she liked what was happening. He felt the little spasms start and knew she was close. Moving one hand off her hip, he reached around and found her little clit, then started rubbing lightly. She moaned around Mike’s cock as he saw his friend jerk and stiffen. The time was close for all of them.
Applying more pressure on Shelby’s clit, he knew she was getting close. He felt the pressure in his balls and he was close, too, he leaned over her and using his deepest Dom voice, said one word in her ear, “Come.”
She did, screaming around Mike’s dick. Her scream no more than finished when Mike came with a groan of his own. Gavin followed them.
Mike collapsed to his knees leaning his head on Shelby’s shoulder. Gavin lay over Shelby, holding her tight. They stayed like that for a few long moments, catching their breath and slowing their racing hearts.
Gavin was the first to move afraid he was crushing Shelby with his weight. He and Mike worked together to release her from the bench. Then he lifted her in his arms carrying her to the big tub Mike had built in one corner of the room. They were going to soak with her in the tub for a while before the three of the crawled into the big bed for a nap.Mike clambered into the tub, and then Gavin settled Shelby on Mike’s lap. Gavin slid himself into the other end of the tub so he sat facing Shelby. He could tell by the glazed look in her eyes that she was still a little out of it. The expression on her face was one of peace and happiness.
Shelby leaned her head back against Mike’s chest and let herself go limp, not that she had much choice. She probably couldn’t have moved if she’d wanted to. Her men were amazing. She’d come more times today than before in one day, although her first day with Gavin was close. Closing her eyes, she let her mind drift, knowing Mike and Gavin would take care of her. She felt them washing her, and then she was lifted, dried, and then carried. She didn’t bother opening her eyes to see where they were going. Placed in the bed, she felt one of the men lay behind her and pull her to him. Then the other man lay in front of her. She relaxed and let her body and mind rest.
Shelby woke later in the big bed in Mike’s room having no idea how long she’d been there or how she’d gotten there. She could hear voices coming from the living room but couldn’t make out what they were saying. Looking around for something to cover herself, she didn’t see anything without going through drawers, or the closet. She grabbed the blanket off the bed and wrapped it around herself, tucking it like a towel in front and throwing the trailing end over her shoulder like a toga. She walked out to where the men sat talking and stood looking at them until Mike pulled her down into his lap.
“Hey, honey, how do you feel?” he asked her and, moving her hair, and brushed her neck with his lips.
She relaxed into his lap and let her contentment show on her face. It was bliss to just let this man hold her. Mike held her for a few minutes before handing her off to Gavin.
“Gavin wants to hold you, too.” He placed her on Gavin’s lap.
The three sat cuddling and talking for a while before, Gavin stood with her and led her back to the bedroom.
“Let’s get you dressed and then we’ll go to my house, and you can get something fancy on. We want to take you to a nice dinner,” he said.
The men took her out for dinner, and then they went back to Mike’s place to sleep since he had the big bed. They were going to have to work out some details, but for now they were going to sleep at Mike’s until they figured everything out.