Each man laid a hand on one of her thighs and turned to look at her.
Gavin started the conversation. “Why did you think we didn’t want you anymore baby? I know what you said earlier, but there has to be more to it.”
“I just got scared when you stopped and Mike walked out of the room. My blow job didn’t even get you off,” Shelby answered, and her tears started again.
“I should have explained that I needed to walk away a minute before I fucked you so hard we both couldn’t move.” Mike grinned and ran his hand up her thigh so that he was tracing patterns on her labia with his fingers.
“Oh,” Shelby said, not sure what else to say. “I…well…okay.”
“Honey, I was so close to coming it was all l could do to hold it back. We wanted you to lose the challenge so we could play with you more. You didn’t disappoint us, honey, as far as I’m concerned you’re perfect,” Gavin said, moving his hand up to her breast and cupping the globe closest to him. Rubbing his thumb back and forth over the nipple he looked earnestly into her eyes.
Mike moved his fingers closer and closer to her clit, gathering her moisture as he delved further into her pussy. “Do you understand now that you didn’t do anything wrong?” Mike asked, brushing his thumb lightly over her clit.
“Yes, I’m sorry. I…just…well,” Shelby stuttered, not sure what she was trying to say.
Mike and Gavin looked at each other. They were going to have to be careful. Shelby’s self-esteem needed building. They could tell she had been knocked down several times in her life, and it would take encouragement to build her back up. They would have to be careful how they treated her until she got her confidence back.
Gavin had explained to Mike what Shelby’s circumstances were when he found her. He had learned more of her background on their trip, and even though he had given Mike some of the details on the phone, they still had a lot to talk about.
“Before we play, I think someone earned a punishment,” Mike said, reaching under the bed and pulling out a bag.
He pulled out what looked like several straps attached to a handle. “This is a flogger, baby. Have you ever seen one before?” he asked, handing it to her.
Shelby took it and felt the straps. They felt soft and didn’t look too bad.
“Take a swing,” Mike told her as both men moved over to give her room to swing it.
Shelby tentatively tried to flip the straps, but it was obvious she didn’t know what she was doing. Smiling Gavin took it from her and expertly snapped the strips in the air.
Watching him twirl the strips around was almost mesmerizing, and Shelby couldn’t take her eyes off the swirling leather. “Doesn’t it hurt?”
“Put you hand out palm up,” Mike instructed.
Shelby did as she was told, and Gavin let the strips brush her hand, at first barely brushing the skin and gradually applying more pressure until she felt a good thumping and the skin was starting to warm up. Gavin continued for a couple minutes before he stopped.
“We want to do that on your bottom and the back of your thighs, and then we would like to turn you over and do the same to your front. Will you try it with us, baby?” Gavin asked her.
Shelby nodded. If it wasn’t any worse than what he did to her hand it wouldn’t be bad.
“Mike has a playroom down in his basement. We want to take you there to play. Come on, baby,” Gavin said.
He and Mike each grabbed a hand and led her out the door and down the hall to a flight of stairs. She was a little self-conscious walking through the house naked, but both men were naked, too, and it didn’t seem to bother them. There was no one else to see them.
Mike led the way down the stairs to a room with a locked door. They stopped in front of the door, and both men stood, arms crossed over their chests and legs spread shoulder width apart.
“I have a similar playroom at my house, and there are some rules you need to know before we go in,” Gavin said.
“The rules I have for my playroom are close to the same rules Gavin has for his,” Mike explained, “and you will be expected to follow them regardless of where we are playing. From now on these rules will apply in the bedroom as well as in here. If you break the rules you will be punished. Before we punish you we will explain what you are being punished for, and we will talk about it.
“The first thing you need to know is you are never allowed to enter either mine or Gavin’s playroom without one of us with you. You are not to go in alone unless we tell you, too. We keep the doors locked at all times so no one can enter except people we want to. You are the only woman ever to be in this room. Gavin and I have played at clubs, but you are the first woman either of us has had in our private playrooms.”
“The second rule is you will always be naked in the playrooms unless we specifically give you something to wear,” Gavin told her.
“The third thing you must remember is in the playroom or the bedroom you will call us Sir or Master—Master Mike or Master Gavin. Understood?”
The look of dominance Mike gave her almost melted her. If she hadn’t locked her knees she’d have been in a puddle on the floor.
“The next rule is you need to answer with words when we ask you a question. We may not always be looking directly at you and may not see you nod or shake your head. Okay?” Gavin explained.