She blew her nose, put the tissue in the toilet, and flushed it. She stood trying to decide what to do next. Shelby walked to the sink and splashed water on her face, looking around for an escape. There were no windows in the room, but there was another door. Shelby opened it hoping it led to a hallway or another means of escape. It was a walk-in closet, the perfect place to hide. Finding a corner under some hanging clothes Shelby sat on the floor and wrapped her arms around her knees, rocking herself and trying to think what to do next. She heard Gavin beating on the bathroom door and calling for her but just ignored it.
Mike came back in the room carrying several bottles of water. Looking at the empty bed, he turned to Gavin with a question on his face.
Gavin answered Mike’s unasked question. “She’s in the bathroom.”
“She’s perfect, isn’t she?” Mike asked Gavin . He couldn’t believe they had finally found the woman he and Gavin had spent years looking for.
He nodded. Taking a bottle of water from Mike, Gavin drank half of it before recapping it. They stood in silence for several minutes, waiting for Shelby to come out.
“Was she okay when she went in there?” Mike knew women could take what seemed like forever in the bath, but he was starting to get concerned.
Gavin nodded and knocked gently on the door. He listened for a minute before knocking again a little harder this time. After waiting another minute or so he really pounded on the door this time, calling out to her as he pounded. Turning the doorknob, he found it locked. He looked at Mike and put his shoulder to the door to knock it down.
Mike stopped him just before he could break the door down and motioned for Gavin to follow him. He led him out to the hall and a door just a few feet away from the bedroom door. Quietly opening the door, he motioned for Gavin to follow him and be quiet.
The two men walked into the closet and stood, listening for the sound of their girl. Mike heard the sobbing first and zeroed in on where Shelby sat crying. He walked up to where she was and squatted down in front of her. Pulling her hands loose from where she had clenched them around her knees, he took them both in his hands.
“What’s the matter, baby?” he asked quietly.
Gavin knelt on the other side of her and started rubbing her back. “Are you cold, baby?” he asked, grabbed one o
f Mike’s shirts, and put around her.
Shelby sobbed harder. Mike and Gavin exchanged looks of confusion, neither one of them knowing what to do next. Gavin sat on the floor Indian style and pulled Shelby onto his lap. Mike kept hold of her hands, not knowing what else to do.
“Did we hurt you, baby?” Gavin asked, scared that they might have. She had seemed okay before going to the bathroom, but something was obviously bothering her.
Shelby shook her head and took a deep breath. “No, you didn’t hurt me physically. Why don’t you want to play with me anymore?” She sobbed.
Gavin and Mike exchanged looks again and Mike asked, “Why do you think that, honey?”
“Because you stopped and Mike left the room. I know I’m not much, but I thought I had pleased both of you. I know I lost the challenge, but give me another chance. Don’t give up on me. I’ll try harder, and you can do anything to me that you want to me. I promise I won’t use my safe word no matter what you do. Please don’t make me leave.” She sobbed, turning her face into Gavin’s chest. She didn’t know what she’d do if she had to leave these men.
Gavin and Mike exchanged a look, and Mike scooted to sit on Shelby’s other side.
“Oh, baby, you didn’t do anything wrong,” Gavin said, taking her face between his hands so he could look into her eyes. “You were and are perfect.” He pulled her face to his for a kiss. “Absolutely perfect. Isn’t she, Mike?”
“Everything we’ve ever wanted in a woman, totally perfect.” Mike took a kiss of his own from Shelby.
Shelby looked at both men and the longing she felt for them was evident in her face. “Really, you think I’m perfect. Why did you stop?” She sniffled.
“Baby, we didn’t stop, we were just taking a little break. We all needed some water, and we wanted to make sure you were okay. We still want to play some more. I think you have a punishment coming. Mike and I have so much more we want to do to and with you.” Gavin wiggled his eyebrows. “Are you willing to play some more?”
Shelby nodded shyly, glad they didn’t want to send her away.
Gavin hugged her tightly, before standing with her in his arms.
Mike stood and took her from Gavin instructing her to wrap her legs around his waist. The shirt Gavin had put around her shoulders fell off leaving them all naked. Gavin stepped up behind them and pressed himself against her.
“Let’s go finish what we started,” he said against her ear as they moved toward the bedroom.
“I believe we have a punishment to administer. Then we are going to fuck you into tomorrow, baby,” Mike said and nibbled on her neck.
The thought of punishment sent a thrill down Shelby’s back. She didn’t know what they were going to do, but she knew they would never hurt her and she always had her safe words.
Mike and Gavin carried her into the bedroom, sat on the side of the bed, and put her between them.
“Before the punishment and fun starts we need to talk about what just happened,” Gavin said.