Gavin held his hand out to her and she placed her small hand is his much larger one. Touching him made her feel more secure. Mike came up on her other side and took her other hand, then led them out the door and across the street. He unlocked the door and led them into his sitting room, and after grabbing beers for him and Gavin and water for Shelby, he sat on one end of the couch opposite Gavin with Shelby between them. They each laid a hand on one of Shelby’s thighs, and as they decided earlier, Mike started the conversation.
“Shelby, we have something we want to talk to you about.”
Shelby didn’t say anything. She just nodded. Crap here it comes.
“Shelby, I know you’re in a relationship with Gavin, but the thing is…Gavin and I like to share women. I’ve been attracted to you since I first saw you in Gavin’s garage, and we would both like you to be our woman.”
Shelby was so prepared for the words “I’m letting you go” that she wasn’t sure she heard Mike right. “Wait…what?” she stammered, looking at Gavin.
“Yes, baby. Mike and I want you to belong to both of us. We are both dominants and we want to have a Dom/sub relationship with you.” Gavin also wanted to tell her they wanted to marry her, but he knew she wasn’t ready for that yet.
Mike couldn’t wait any longer and slipped his arms around Shelby and pulled her into his lap. Gavin moved closer to the middle of the couch and pulled her feet into his lap, he needed to touch her, too. Mike tilted her face to his and brushed her mouth in a chaste kiss. He wanted more but didn’t want to scare her.
Shelby wrapped her hand around Mike’s neck and pulled his head closer to hers. She put her lips on his and, using her tongue, traced the seam of his lips, showing him with her mouth she was ready for what he wanted.
Mike didn’t need to be told twice and slid his tongue into her mouth, claiming her as his. While he was kissing her, he moved his hand down her side to where her shirt was tucked into her jeans and pulled it loose. He moved his hand underneath it and walked his fingers up the smooth skin of her stomach to her bra-covered breast. Cupping the small firm globe in his hand, he ran his thumb over her cloth-covered nipple, never losing contact with her mouth. Pulling back for breath, he sat her up in his lap, where both he and Gavin could see her face.
Shelby looked at both of them wide-eyed and took a deep breath. “You both want me, together at the same time?” she asked, full of wonder.
She couldn’t believe she was lucky enough to have one man, let alone two, want her. She hadn’t really thought about it until now, but the day she found out about her parents, Mike had shown how much he cared for her. He had held her and made sure she was taken care of until Gavin arrived. Gavin, how did he feel about all of this?
Shelby looked at Gavin and took his face in her hands. “Do you want this, too?” She watched his face carefully.
Gavin smiled and leaning over took her mouth with a kiss, showing her how much he wanted it. When Gavin broke the kiss Shelby leaned back and looked at both men.
“Both of you at the same time. You’ll both be okay with that? You won’t be jealous of each other?”
“No, honey. Gavin’s my best bud. We’ve been friends forever and have been talking about sharing a woman for years. We just never found the right woman until you came along,” Mike said, settling her more comfortably on his lap.
Gavin still had her feet across his legs and started removing her shoes and socks. “Baby, this is something Mike and I have wanted for a long time. We both care deeply for you. Mike just held back until he knew I was willing to share you. This is up to you, though. This won’t work unless we all try.”
Mike broke in. “Shelby you have to be on board with all of it, and you need to know there are times that I will spend time with you without Gavin around, and he will spend time with you without me, and of course, we will both have you together.”
While he talked he lifted it up over her stomach, not quite exposing her bra and breasts, but close.
“So what do you think? Do you want to try this with us?” Gavin asked.
Shelby looked at both men and thought for a minute. Did she want this? She had read a few books about it but never thought she would find one man let alone two that wanted to be with her. Could she be with two dominant men? Gavin had shown her a little of his dominant side, but she hadn’t seen Mike’s yet. Could she be what both men needed and wanted?
Looking at both men again she asked, “What if I’m not enough? What if I can’t do this?”
Gavin was sure she was the one and that it wouldn’t be a problem. “Shelby, you will be enough, and if it doesn’t work out for some reason, we’ll deal with that then. But, baby, I’m sure you’re the one for us. Enough talk, time for us to show you.” He finished undoing her jeans.
“Yeah, enough talk,” Mike murmured, pulling her T-shirt over her head. “Time to play.”
Before Shelby realized what was going on, both men had her naked, and she was being carried toward the back of the house.
“Where are we going?” she asked, a little anxious about what was going to happen.
“I’m taking you back to my bedroom,” Mike answered.
Part of the reason Mike and Gavin had decided to begin this at his house was that Mike had a custom-made bed that was large enough not only for him but for several other people, too. Mike also had a playroom in his basement that he and Gavin had worked on together.
Mike sat on the side of the bed, and Gavin sat beside him. They looked at Shelby.
“Are you sure you want this, baby?” Gavin wanted to make sure they weren’t pushing her.
“Yes, I want both of you,” Shelby answered, putting one hand of each of their thighs.