When I returned, Grace was feeding Ty’s dick into her wet pussy. She sank all the way down and sat for a second. She was looking at Ty, their eyes locked in a private conversation. I was almost jealous she hadn’t looked at me that way, but that was my own fault. I needed to work hard to earn her trust. She may have let me fuck her, but the two of them had a deeper connection.
Ty hissed when Grace scratched her nails down his front and then lifted and sank back on his cock. She picked up the pace and rode him hard. Ty moaned and gripped her hips.
I knew it was his turn, but I couldn’t stand not touching her anymore. Grace locked eyes with me as I approached the bed. Ty thrust up, and Grace’s eyes rolled back. I saw her grab Ty’s forearms and lean a little forward.
Was she giving me her backside?
I walked up behind her and ran my fingers up and down her spine. Her skin broke out in goosebumps along with the droplets of sweat. If she was going to be ours, then we needed to make sure she knew we wanted to play everywhere, including sinking deep in her tight little ass. Since I got to have her pussy first, Ty would be the first to claim her ass.
I ran my fingers down to the base of her spine and then shifted my thumb between her cheeks.
“Fuck,” he shouted when I touched Grace’s rosebud. “Do that again. She’s squeezing my dick so hard. Holy fucking shit.”
I chuckled at Ty. I knew what it felt to be on the receiving end of her pussy. It was fantastic.
“Have you had anyone in here before?” I asked as I brushed my thumb over the puckered hole again.
She nodded and swallowed back a moan. “Yes.”
I groaned. Shit. We were going to have to table that conversation for later because that meant we could play a whole lot more than we thought.
“Peaches, you keep surprising me. You like it hard, you like to take control, and you like it a little dirty. I can’t wait to find out more.” I pushed the tip of my thumb past the tight ring of muscle.
Grace rose up and slammed back down on Ty, shuddering her release. Her head was thrown back with a silent scream.
Ty let out a string of curses along with her name as he followed her into the abyss.
I kissed her shoulder before removing my thumb. Grace gave a little hiss and collapsed onto Ty’s chest. I went into the bathroom to wash up and grab a warm washcloth for Grace. She had shifted off Ty, but the two of them had remained where I’d left them. I chuckled to myself. If only I had been with her second, I would have been able to lie with her longer. Next time.
I gently took care of Grace, tossing the cloth in the wet pile of Ty’s clothes. I pulled back the covers and lifted Grace carefully, so she was settled in the middle of the bed. I climbed in beside her and pulled Grace to me. I guess it was a good thing after all that I was first. While Ty took care of himself, I got to take care of Grace and get her snuggled up to me before he even got back.
“Rest up, peaches. We have more planned for you tonight,” I whispered against her temple.
“Is that so?” She looked up from my chest and smiled sleepily.
I placed a soft kiss on her lips. My heart tugged. Now that blood was back in the right head, I was beginning to remember why I resisted her in the first place. I needed to pull back. My fear of falling for her reared its ugly head, but I shoved it away for now. I’d deal with that tomorrow. Now that I’d gotten a taste of her, I wanted more. I just didn’t know what to do about my conflicting feelings.
I let Grace sleep for an hour before waking her up with my face buried between her thighs. She was so sweet, I wanted to drink her up. Ty played with her ass after I wrung two orgasms from her. She was so responsive to us, it was crazy.
I couldn’t decide what was the best part of the night. Eating her out, having her suck me off while Ty had a finger in her ass, watching her sit on Ty’s face, or either of the two times I was balls deep in her pussy. I didn’t care that I was only getting an hour or two of sleep before heading out on rotation. I had no doubt Ty thought the same. It made coming back all that much sweeter.
A thumping soundbrought me out of a good sleep. I was wrapped around Grace’s backside holding her close to me. The banging sound happened again.
What the fuck?
I looked at the clock. We weren’t late. On rotation mornings, we didn’t have to get up until seven o’clock. It was seven thirty, but Ty and I didn’t take long to get ready.
Who was pounding on the door?
I pulled away from Grace’s warm body and threw on my sweats. I didn’t bother with my boxers since I planned on getting back in bed and going one more round with Grace before we headed out. Both Ty and Grace stirred.
“What’s up?” Ty mumbled.
“Not sure. I’ll be right back.”
I made my way to the front door where the unusual pounding continued. When I opened the door, I was greeted by the huge head of a big gray horse.
Storm.
What was he doing here?
“Morning, Storm.” I jerked my chin in greeting.
“Uh, Grace?” I called. “I think it’s for you.”
“Who is it?” I heard her call out, but before I could answer, Storm whinnied. Normally, I’d say this was a weird situation, but I’d seen the way Blake trained her horses.
“Oh shit, is that the time?” Grace’s frantic voice filtered down the hall, followed by thudding sounds.
Grace sprinted down the hall barefooted and with one of Ty’s shirts thrown on over a pair of boxers I knew weren’t hers. Damn, she looked adorable.
“I’m going to be so late.” She breezed by me and out the door. Storm had backed up off my porch when Grace had yelled down the hall, so she was able to swing up onto him bareback from the top of the two steps. They took off in the direction of the bunkhouse. I didn’t know if I should be stunned by the scene that had just happened or to fall over laughing. I chuckled as I made my way down the hall toward Ty’s room.
“Did she just leave in my boxers and your shirt?”
“Umm, yep.” He bent down, picking up her bra and underwear.
I guess that was one way to end an amazing night. And a gentle reminder that it was tomorrow, and I needed to let her go before my heart got too tangled up in all this.