“Now, Haley, let’s have a real conversation.”
She nods as I feed her bites of the omelet, humming her enjoyment. She subtly rubs her pussy lips against my dick, trying to gain friction. I smile at her efforts but make no move to encourage it. That hungry snatch begs me for it, and I leak pre-cum, loving the way she feels against me.
“Pay attention, Haley, or I’ll take your cock toy away.”
She does this cute little pout thing with her bottom lip that makes me laugh.
“Yes, Daddy.”
“Haley, do you know why I’ve brought you here and done these things to you?”
“Because I was in danger at the party and you were protecting me?”
“Yes, that’s part of the reason you ended up here. But my decision to take you physically and finally make you mine has been something I’ve struggled with for years.”
I sigh heavily as I feed her more of her dinner and try to explain without sounding like a creep.
“Haley, I have loved you as my own daughter since the day you were born. I’ve watched you grow into a young girl and then into a young woman. I’ve never in my life felt this way about anyone. I haven’t been able to look at another woman in years. I haven’t touched another woman in years. At your sweet sixteen pool party I saw your top fall off, and I wasn’t able to stop my feelings from turning from paternal to sexual.”
I take another deep breath and disclose the full extent of my depravity.
“I only want you, Haley. I know how you’ve always watched me. I know you’ve always fantasized about me. I saw all those looks you gave me for years. But I never allowed myself to see you in that way. Until then. Once I lowered that wall and saw you sexually, there was no turning back. I want to own you. I want to be the man in your life. I want to be the one to ripen you sexually, and also the one who helps you grow up. I want you to go to college and choose a career, if that’s what you want to do. I want to be there for every milestone in your life. I want to be the man who awaits you at the end of the aisle, not the one who gives you away. I want to be the one to give you babies when you’re ready, and I want your life to be entwined with mine.”
Her eyes are so big at my confession, I don’t know what she is thinking.
“Haley, I don’t want to scare you, but because you’re so young and I’m so much older, this will be a problem for a lot of people. This may potentially ruin any friendship I have with your father and any relationship you have with him too. You don’t have to decide right this moment what you want to do, but I need you to know my intentions are not pure. I want your decisions to be made by me. I want to be your Daddy forever. This isn’t something I do lightly, and I think it’s only fair to let you decide how much of this is just a fantasy of yours, and how much you want to come true.”
I pause and look deep into her eyes, holding her face so she doesn’t mistake anything I am about to say.
“I am going to take your body like a man takes a woman. I am going to fuck you to death and then back to life. I will forever own you physically, but I’m also asking for your heart. Nothing you say will change what happens tomorrow. That sweet cherry of yours will be mine. But the decision to leave or stay afterward is up to you.”
Even though I told her that I would let her leave tomorrow if she chooses to, I know I won’t let her. I would do anything and everything to try to get her to stay of her own free will. But if push comes to shove, I have no problem tying her ass to my bed and making sure she craves what only I can give her.
She starts to speak, but I place a finger over her lips.
“Shh. Don’t answer now, my sweet little Haley. We’ve had a big day and it’s time for bed.”
I open her thighs a little and move my hard cock—now covered in her pussy cream—away from her heat. She makes a small sound of protest, and I just smile. I love how much her body craves me. I stand her up and lead her to the bedroom, leaving the dirty plates on the table. My housekeeper will get them in the morning.
When we get to the bedroom, I pull back the covers and she slides in. I take off my shorts and spoon her from behind. I reach back and turn off the lamp, sending the room into darkness. When I pull her to me, her lush ass pushes back and my dick slides right between her folds, and I can feel the head of my cock against her clit. My whole length nestles against her, and I smile. I palm her tits as I close my eyes, completely content.
“I love you, Daddy,” she whispers softly as I feel her fall asleep in my arms.
Finally. I finally have everything I’ve ever wanted in my arms. I just need to figure out how to hold on to it.
Five
HALEY
I wake up on top of Daddy William, and it brings forth a torrent of memories from the previous day. Sliding to the side, I rest my chin on my hand to better study him. He looks so relaxed. Much more at ease than I can recall him looking in a very long time. After what he told me last night, I know I was the cause of his tension when he was around me. As much as it broke my heart to hear that he had been pining for me as he thought he couldn’t have me, it also filled me with joy. William wants to be mine. Not only that, but he wants me to be his in every way. I want that too. Part of me thinks he didn’t want me to tell him how I felt last night because he was scared of what I might say. I don’t want to let him think for one more second that I don’t want everything he wants.