For a two-time defending champion, this must have hurt. The New England Interscholastic Wrestling Championships had begun in '49, fourteen years after Al Frost finished his third undefeated season, but in the Favorite River school newspaper, nothing was said about Al Frost's record--or Kittredge's failure to tie it. In thirteen years, there'd been eighteen two-time New England champions--Kittredge among them. If he'd managed to win a third championship, that would have been a first. "A first and a last," Coach Hoyt was quoted as saying, in our school newspaper. As it would turn out, '61 was the final year there were all-inclusive New England schoolboy wrestling championships; starting in '62, the public high schools and the private schools would have separate tournaments.
I asked Herm Hoyt about it one early spring day, when our paths crossed in the quad. "Somethin' will be lost--havin' one tournament for everyone is tougher," the old coach told me.
I asked Coach Hoyt about Kittredge, too--if there was anything that could explain those two losses. "Kittredge didn't give a shit about that consolation match," Herm said. "If he couldn't win it all, he didn't give a good fuck about the difference between third and fourth place."
"What about the first loss?" I asked Coach Hoyt.
"I kept tellin' Kittredge, there's always someone who's better," the old coach said. "The only way you beat the better guy is by bein' tougher. The other guy was better, and Kittredge wasn't tougher."
That seemed to be all there was to it. Atkins and I found Kittredge's defeat anticlimactic. When I mentioned it to Richard Abbott, he said, "It's Shakespearean, Bill; lots of the important stuff in Shakespeare happens offstage--you just hear about it."
"It's Shakespearean," I repeated.
"It's still anticlimactic," Atkins said, when I told him what Richard had to say.
As for Kittredge, he seemed only a little subdued; he didn't strike me as much affected by those losses. Besides, it was that time in our senior year when we were hearing about what colleges or universities we'd been admitted to. The wrestling season was over.
Favorite River was not in the top tier of New England preparatory schools; understandably, the academy kids didn't apply to the top tier of colleges or universities. Most of us went to small liberal-arts colleges, but Tom Atkins saw himself as a state-university type; he'd seen what small was like, and what he wanted was bigger--"a place you could get lost in," Atkins wistfully said to me.
I cared less about the getting-lost factor than Tom Atkins did. I cared about the English Department--whether or not I could continue to read those writers Miss Frost had introduced me to. I cared about being in or near New York City.
"Where'd you go to college?" I had asked Miss Frost.
"Someplace in Pennsylvania," she'd told me. "It's no place you've ever heard of." (I liked the "no place you've ever heard of" part, but it was the New York City factor that mattered most to me.)
I applied to every college and university I could think of in the New York City area--ones you've heard of, ones you've never heard of. I made a point of speaking to someone in the German Department, too. In every case, I was assured that they would help me find a way to study abroad in a German-speaking country.
I already had the feeling that a summer in Europe with Tom Atkins would only serve to stimulate my desire to be far, far away from First Sister, Vermont. It seemed to me to be what a would-be writer should do--that is, live in a foreign country, where they spoke a foreign language, while (at the same time) I would be making my earliest serious attempts to write in my own language, as if I were the first and only person to ever do it.
Tom Atkins ended up at the University of Massachusetts, in Amherst; it was a big school, and Atkins would manage to get lost there--maybe more lost than he'd meant, or had wanted.
No doubt, my application to the University of New Hampshire provoked some suspicion at home. There'd been a rumor that Miss Frost was moving to New Hampshire. This had prompted Aunt Muriel to remark that she wished Miss Frost were moving farther away from Vermont than that--to which I responded by saying I hoped to move farther away from Vermont than that, too. (This must have mystified Muriel, who knew I'd applied to the University of New Hampshire.)
But that spring, there was no confirmation that Miss Frost's rumored move to New Hampshire was true--nor did anyone say where in New Hampshire she might be moving to. Truly, my reasons for applying to the University of New Hampshire had nothing to do with Miss Frost's future whereabouts. (I'd only applied there to worry my family--I had no intention of going there.)
It was frankly more of a mystery--chiefly, to Tom Atkins and me--that Kittredge was going to Yale. Granted, Atkins and I had the kind of SAT scores that made Yale--or any of the Ivy League schools--unattainable. My grades had been better than Kittredge's, however, and how could Yale have overlooked the fact that Kittredge had been forced to repeat his senior year? (Tom Atkins had erratic grades, but he had graduated on schedule.) Atkins and I knew that Kittredge had great SAT scores, but Yale must have been motivated to take him for other reasons; Atkins and I knew that, too.
Atkins mentioned Kittredge's wrestling, but I think I know what Miss Frost would have said about that: It wasn't the wrestling that got Kittredge into Yale.
(As it turned out, he wouldn't wrestle in college, anyway.) His SAT scores probably helped, but Kittredge's father, from whom he was estranged, had gone to Yale.
"Trust me," I told Tom. "Kittredge didn't get into Yale for his German--that's all I can tell you."
"Why does it matter to you, Billy--where Kittredge is going to college?" Mrs. Hadley asked me. (I was having a pronunciation problem with the Yale word, which was why the subject came up.)
"I'm not envious," I told her. "I assure you, I don't want to go there--I can't even say it!"
As it turned out, it meant nothing--where Kittredge went to college, or where I went--but, at the time, it was infuriating that Kittredge was accepted to Yale.
"Forget about fairness," I said to Martha Hadley, "but doesn't merit matter?" It was an eighteen-year-old question to ask, though I had turned nineteen (in March 1961); in due time, of course, I would get over where Kittredge went to college. Even in that spring of '61, Tom Atkins and I were more interested in planning our summer in Europe than we were obsessed by the obvious injustice of Kittredge getting into Yale.
I admit: It was easier to forget about Kittredge, now that I rarely saw him. Either he didn't need my help with his German or he'd stopped asking for it. Since Yale had admitted him, Kittredge wasn't worried about what grade he got in German--all he had to do was graduate.
"May I remind you?" Tom Atkins asked me sniffily. "Graduating was all Kittredge had to do last year, too."
But in '61, Kittredge did graduate--so did we all. Frankly, graduation seemed anticlimactic, too. Nothing happened, but what were we expecting? Apparently, Mrs. Kittredge hadn't been expecting anything; she didn't attend. Elaine also stayed away, but that was understandable.
Why hadn't Mrs. Kittredge come to see her only child graduate? ("Not very motherly, is she?" was all Kittredge had to say about it.) Kittredge seemed unsurprised; he was notably unimpressed with graduating. His aura was one of already having moved beyond the rest of us.