“I think she just had her first orgasm,” Andrew said with a smile.
Slowly, the world seemed to right itself as Andrew lay on the bed on the other side of her. Once again, she was sandwiched between her men and she liked the feel of their big hard bodies surrounding hers.
“Did you like it when I spanked your pussy?” Andrew asked.
What was she supposed to say? It seemed so unnatural when his finger rubbed her ass, and yet when he spanked her pussy, a rush of heat consumed her. Would they think she was a wanton? Was she?
“Answer Andrew, Mary. We’re your husbands and you must be honest with us. We want to give you everything you like. We want to know what excites you.”
With a sigh, she quietly said, “Yes. Is that bad?”
They pulled her into an embrace between them.
“Not at all. We love to see you come. Between the three of us, whatever we enjoy is not wrong. That’s what makes our marriage work, keeping each other happy. Now it’s time for me to take your maidenhood. Be prepared for it to hurt just a little, but once it’s gone, it will never hurt again.”
Why did this sound so scary? And yet, she also was intrigued as to what else they would show her tonight. At this moment, she had enjoyed their touching, kissing, and even fondling between her legs. But she still feared them touching her ass.
Jesse rolled onto his back and Andrew lifted her and placed the entrance to her cunny right on top of his cock. She glanced down at the size.
“Jesse…” she said, fear rippling through her.
“Now, darling, you’re going to love my cock filling you. Try to relax and I’ll do my best not to hurt you.”
Raising just a little, Jesse kissed her again on the lips, nibbling at her bottom lip as heat began to swirl inside her once again.
Breaking the kiss, Jesse smiled at her, his fingers tweaking her clit, sending passion flowing through her. They had her so aroused, she didn’t know what was next, but she wanted more. She needed more.
“Honey, tonight you’re going to love the feel of my cock inside you,” Jesse said, his voice deep and low, vibrating through her.
With Andrew’s help, she sank a little lower onto his cock and then she felt him stretching and filling her. For a moment, she didn’t dare move, but then he gave a little shove and she felt the membrane give from the pressure. A gasp escaped her as she slid the rest of the way down to sit on his stomach.
“Now you belong to us. Never forget you’re our wife. Ride my cock.”
Was this what people had been doing since the beginning of time? The first few moments were awkward as she rose and slid down his cock, but then the friction between them began and she moaned as she felt her pussy clenching around his cock. Pleasure had her moaning, her breathing rapid and fast.
His hands were on her breasts as he tugged and pinched her nipples, spreading hot lava through her body. With a moan, she closed her eyes and let her head roll back.
“Open your eyes, Mary. I want to see the passion in your gaze. I want to stare at you when you come.”
Once again, she opened her eyes, her breathing was harsh and then she felt Andrew rubbing his finger at her back entrance. She tried not to panic as he slid his finger into her ass, swirling it around. A burst of desire went off inside her like a bomb and she leaned back into Andrew.
“Andrew,” she groaned, still wondering how it could feel so good to have his finger inside her ass. “Please, do something.”
How could something so depraved feel so good? She’d never imagined a man’s finger bringing her so much pleasure.
“Don’t come,” Jesse said.
How was she supposed to stop the rush of heat filling her, flooding her, and making her want to desperately find release?
“Hold on,” he said. “I’m almost there."
She groaned and it was all she could do not to scream with frustration.
“Now,” Jesse said.
It was then that Andrew’s hand landed on her ass, his finger buried deep inside her and she screamed as her body convulsed.
“Oh, Jesse,” she cried. “Andrew, oh, what is happening?”
Panting, she never imagined what Jesse said would be true. That she would loudly proclaim her pleasure. That the feel of Andrew’s hand landing on her ass would send her over the edge, falling into that blissful oblivion.
Drained, she slumped onto Jesse’s strong chest, knowing that today, she had made one of the best decisions of her life. Marrying her husbands.
Andrew let her rest until her breathing slowed. “My turn, Mary. I can’t wait to come inside your pussy.”
How could she endure anymore? How could she take another round? And yet her body was already awakening.
“Watching you fuck Jesse, I’m rock hard and ready to explode. This is going to be hard and fast.”
What did he mean by hard and fast? He rolled her onto her back and pulled her to the edge of the bed. Then he lined up his cock with her cunny. He slid inside her, gripping her hips and lifting her to meet him.
Suddenly he grabbed her legs and spread her wide, opening her to his cock. In amazement, she watched as his cock slid in and out of her pussy. Once again, the pressure was mounting inside her and she clenched his cock.
“That’s it, darling,” he cried. “Squeeze me.”